22–25 Jul 2025
Atlantic/Canary timezone

Meta-Analysis on the Effectiveness of Psychological Interventions: A Study on Replicability and Reproducibility

23 Jul 2025, 11:30
30m
Poster Statistical analyses Poster Session 1

Abstract

In recent years, the importance of meta-analyses has been highlighted within the context of evidence-based practice. The reproducibility and replicability of meta-analyses have become critical areas of research due to the inherent complexity in data extraction and analysis. Conducting a meta-analysis involves a series of methodological decisions and steps that can significantly influence the final results.
This study aims to assess the reproducibility and replicability of meta-analyses related to the effectiveness of psychological interventions.
The reproducibility and replicability of the results of 8 randomly selected meta-analyses were empirically evaluated from a pool of 100 meta-analyses published on the effectiveness of psychological interventions.
Statistical data were extracted from individual studies, effect sizes for each individual study were calculated, meta-analytic computations were performed, and the results were compared with those of the original meta-analyses.
The potential implications of errors and inconsistencies in this process are analyzed.

Funding: MICIU/AEI /10.13039/501100011033/ and FEDER funds, European Union, grant no. PID2022-137328NB-I00

Poster Psychological Interventions: A Study on Replicability and Reproducibility
Author Julio Sánchez-Meca (1), Laura Badenes-Ribera (2), Rosa María Núñez-Núñez (3) and María Rubio-Aparicio (1)
Affiliation (1) University of Murcia, (2) University of Valencia, (3) Miguel Hernández University
Keywords Meta-analysis, effect size, replicability

Primary authors

Dr Julio Sánchez-Meca (University of Murcia (Spain)) Dr Laura Badenes-Ribera (University of Valencia (Spain)) Dr María Rubio-Aparicio (University of Murcia (Spain)) Dr Rosa M. Núñez-Núñez (University Miguel Hernández (Spain))

Presentation materials

There are no materials yet.